top of page

5+ stars for Would You Rather... by Kimberly Baer #yalit #youngadult #yathriller #bookreview

N. N. Light


Title: Would You Rather…

Author: Kimberly Baer

Genre: Young Adult

 

Book Blurb:

 

Pick a card, any card…

 

Would you rather be an amazing artist or a brilliant mathematician?

 

Would you rather lose your mother or your father?

 

Would you rather roast to death or freeze to death?

 

It’s a silly game hosted by a substitute teacher, an exercise in exploring the workings of the teenage mind. Twenty-three students make their choices, and the game is forgotten—until the chosen scenarios start coming true. Classmates Ava, Blake, and Charlie are determined to track down the mysterious teacher and persuade him to end the curse. But the clock is ticking, lives hang in the balance, and the foe they seek is more menacing than they could imagine.

 

My Review:

 

Kimberly Baer’s Would You Rather… is the latest great read in the exciting Haunting of Pinedale High series, brought to us by the talented YA authors at The Wild Rose Press. This book is a perfect addition to the series, offering a thrilling blend of suspense, creativity, and fun.

 

The story kicks off with a seemingly harmless game of “Would You Rather” hosted by a mysterious substitute teacher. The students are asked to choose between unsettling scenarios: Would you rather be an amazing artist or a brilliant mathematician? Would you rather lose your mother or your father? Would you rather roast to death or freeze to death? What begins as a playful exercise quickly turns sinister when the choices made by the students start coming true.

 

As the game spirals out of control, classmates Ava, Blake, and Charlie must race against time to find the elusive substitute teacher and convince him to end the curse before more lives are lost. The pressure mounts as they discover the teacher’s role in this dark, twisted situation—and the true danger they face is far worse than they imagined.

 

Baer’s writing is fast-paced and engaging, with short chapters that make it easy to keep turning the pages. I was glued to it from page one. The alternating character perspectives add depth and keep the story fresh, giving readers a chance to see the unfolding events through different lenses. The characters are all unique and have their own distinct personalities—one in particular even had me laughing out loud.

 

Would You Rather… is an imaginative, thoroughly entertaining read that perfectly captures the suspenseful spirit of the Haunting of Pinedale High series. It’s a must-read for fans of YA thrillers, and I highly recommend it to anyone looking for a gripping, fun story that will keep you hooked from start to finish.

 

My Rating: 5+ stars

 

Buy it Now:   

 

 

 

 

 

Author Biography:

 

Kimberly Baer wrote her first story at age six. It was about a baby chick that hatched out of a little girl's Easter egg after somehow surviving the hard-boiling process. Nowadays she writes in a variety of genres, including young adult, middle-grade, and adult romantic suspense. She lives in Virginia, where she likes to go power-walking on days when it's not too hot, too cold, too rainy, too snowy, or too windy. On indoor days, you’re likely to find her hard at work on her next novel or binge-watching old episodes of Survivor, her favorite guilty pleasure.

 

Social Media Links:

 

 

Reviewed by: Lana

©2015-2025 BY N. N. LIGHT. ALL RIGHTS RESERVED. (2015-17 on Wordpress) 

bottom of page